Here’s your
hand, sitting South:
♠ J
♥ Q
♦ AJ98652
♣ KQ98
Here’s the
bidding:
Auction:
|
West
|
North
|
East
|
South
|
|
1D
|
2D*
|
P
|
?
|
·
Michaels,
showing a hand containing at least 5 hearts and 5 spades
Ah, this is
a puzzle. Partner has cue bid your seven card suit! But it’s a conventional
bid, Michaels, showing two five card majors. What to do?
This was a
hand I played with my former partner, Mille Garrison, in a four section, two
game event in the 1996 Palms Springs Regional Tournament against some of the
best players in the world. Millie was sitting West and I was sitting East.
In this
hand, this South passed. Millie, West, also passed so North had to play the
hand in 2D, a suit in which he was void.
|
|
North
♠ AKT9654
♥ A97643
♦ Void
♣ Void
|
|
|
West
♠ 73
♥ K
♦ KQT74
♣ AJ732
|
|
East
♠ Q82
♥ JT852
♦ 3
♣ T654
|
|
|
South
♠ J
♥ Q
♦ AJ98652
♣ KQ98
|
|
Auction:
|
West
|
North
|
East
|
South
|
|
1D
|
2D
|
P
|
P
|
|
P
|
|
|
|
Bidding: This is a shining example of why
Michaels is not always the best way to show a huge 2-suiter. People think that
if they have a two-suited hand, they should always use it. I don’t agree. North
misbid. There is no way that his partner could know he had a hand that was 7-6.
He should overcall Millie’s 1D with 1S and then jump to 4 hearts with his
second bid, letting partner choose which suit. And partner, given two singleton
honors, should take him back to his first suit.
If North
bid Michaels, as here, and if East passed, as here, then South should bid 2
spades. Partner can’t possibly know the shape of that hand. Here, who wouldn’t
be tempted to pass 2 diamonds with a seven card suit headed by the AJ, even if
LHO did open 1D?
However,
since his LHO, West, opened with South’s 7 card suit, there’s a good
possibility that West has four diamonds (you know she has at least three), so
how many diamonds could North have? He’s already shown an unbalanced hand, so
the chances of him having more than one are slim and the chances of his being
void are excellent. So if you think about it, you shouldn’t be tempted to pass
and take the chance that your partner will be forced to play this in a suit in
which he is obviously horribly short. If partner shows two 5-card majors (which
is all Michaels promises), and your RHO passes, make a choice between the two,
even if you have two singletons.
Play: As East, I led the 4 of clubs,
Millie taking South’s king with her ace. She smothered the singleton queen of
hearts by leading her king. While South could get rid of one club on the AK
spades, South was doomed to play the hand out of her hand and we got 2 club
tricks and 4 diamond tricks for down one. Because Millie had five clubs, she
could always take South’s diamond lead and force him to ruff and lead into her
again. My club ten backed up by three other clubs was a huge card for the
defense, keeping South from getting any club other than the queen.
Other
tables were playing the hand in 4 spades, making, losing a spade and two
hearts. I don’t know how they bid it. We were the only table at which North
played the hand in 2D. It was the last hand of the day for us. We set it one
trick and it gave us the best score in the room on this hand which was enough
for us to win the 64 table event.
